The current situation in New Zealand’s healthcare system is dire, marked by a severe
disconnect between government agencies responsible for workforce management. Despite
a well-documented shortage of nurses, recent graduates and international nurses find
themselves without jobs, leading to growing frustration and an exodus of qualified
professionals to countries like Australia.
The recent reports and experiences from healthcare professionals paint a bleak picture of a
system teetering on the brink of collapse.
Despite the well-documented shortage of nurses, the system has paradoxically created an
‘artificial glut,’ where recent graduates and experienced international nurses are struggling
to find employment. This bizarre situation is clearly due to inconsistent and poorly
coordinated policies among government agencies, which have failed to address the real
needs of the healthcare system. Instead of streamlining the hiring process and making it
easier for qualified nurses to find work, the government has effectively side-lined these
professionals, leading to growing frustration and disillusionment within the workforce.
One of the primary issues is the mismanagement and lack of clear roles within the newly
restructured health system. The 2022 health reforms aimed to centralise and streamline
public health services by consolidating the functions of the former district health boards
into two national agencies—Te Whatu Ora and the Public Health Agency (PHA). However,
instead of creating a more efficient system, these reforms have led to confusion and
inefficiency. A recent review highlighted that these agencies often duplicate efforts, with
multiple groups handling the same tasks without proper coordination, leading to delays and
confusion in critical situations, such as during the recent measles outbreak.
The result of this disarray is a healthcare system where essential services are compromised.
Nurses, especially those working in emergency departments, report extreme stress and
burnout, often finding themselves unable to provide the level of care patients need.
Patients are left waiting in ambulances, lying in corridors with untreated pain, and facing
delays that can have life-threatening consequences. These conditions are not just anecdotal
but are widespread across the country, reflecting a system that has been underfunded and
mismanaged for years.
The lack of coordination is also evident in the recruitment and retention of nurses. The
government’s decision to freeze recruitment in certain areas, combined with inadequate
pay parity across different sectors of nursing, has driven many nurses to leave New Zealand
for better prospects in Australia. The New Zealand Nurses Organisation (NZNO) has been
vocal about the need for pay parity across different healthcare settings to ensure that
nurses are not forced to choose jobs based on pay disparities, but rather on where they are
most needed.
Moreover, the situation is further complicated by the recent cuts in funding and resources,
which have made it difficult for the healthcare system to cope with the ongoing demands.
The reforms that were supposed to address the issues exposed by the COVID-19 pandemic
have instead led to more fragmentation, with agencies struggling to collaborate effectively.
This has had real-world impacts, such as delays in the notification of infectious diseases and
challenges in managing outbreaks, which could have severe consequences for public health.
In light of these challenges, there is an urgent need for the government to take decisive
action. This includes overhauling the recruitment process, ensuring better coordination
between agencies, and providing adequate funding to support the healthcare system.
Without these changes, New Zealand risks losing more of its qualified healthcare
professionals, which would further exacerbate the crisis and put the health and safety of its
citizens at even greater risk.
The well-being of the nation depends on the healthcare system, and the time for action is
now.
ISSUE
